Resurfacing vs Replacing a Driveway: Which Is Better?

When your driveway starts to show signs of wear, it’s natural to wonder whether a repair or a full replacement is needed. Deciding whether to resurface your driveway or opt for a full driveway replacement goes beyond just driveway repair costs – it involves lifespan, safety, and the appearance of your property.

Resurfacing vs Replacing a Driveway

At C. Brooks Paving, we’ve provided trusted repair services throughout Bulverde, the Hill Country, and South Texas. Let’s walk through the pros, cons, and factors that determine the better option for your asphalt or concrete driveway.

The Basics

Before diving into pros and cons, understand what each solution means for your driveway repair options.

What Is Driveway Resurfacing?

Driveway resurfacing involves applying a new layer of asphalt over the existing driveway. It works well when the surface has minor cracks, potholes, or fading but the base remains intact. Think of it as a cleaning and patch job with a fresh finish quick and cost-effective for mild surface damage.

What Is Driveway Replacement?

Driveway replacement means removing the old asphalt or concrete, repairing or rebuilding the base, and installing a new driveway. This is essential when deeper structural issues exist or when the driveway has exceeded its expected lifespan.

Key Differences: What Sets Resurfacing and Replacement Apart?

Cost Considerations

• Resurfacing a driveway usually costs significantly less often a fraction of the cost of full replacement.
  
• Replacing the driveway requires more materials and labor but may save you money over time if structural repairs are necessary.
  

Time and Disruption

• Resurfacing takes 1–2 days.
  
• A full replacement may take 3–5 days, depending on weather and site conditions.
  

Lifespan and Durability

• Resurfacing extends the life of your driveway by 8–10 years.
  
• Driveway replacement can last 20–30 years, especially with proper installation and driveway care.
  

Signs You Should Consider Resurfacing

Choose to resurface your driveway if:

• Small cracks and surface-level wear are visible
  
• The color has faded or the texture is worn
  
• You see surface potholes but no base failure
  
• No drainage or structural issues exist
  
• The driveway is under 15 years old
  

Signs It’s Time for a Full Replacement

It might be time to replace your driveway if:

• You notice deep cracks, especially “alligator” patterns
  
• There are cracks in your concrete or water pooling
  
• Past repairs or patch jobs have failed
  
• The driveway is over 20 years old
  
• You’re seeing erosion or unstable soil conditions
  

Factors That Affect the Right Choice

Driveway Age

A 20-year-old driveway is often due for full replacement, especially if it’s been patched multiple times.

Soil Conditions

Poor drainage or unstable soil requires regrading and new installation, making resurfacing unsuitable.

Type of Use

A concrete driveway used by heavy vehicles or equipment may need repair more frequently, and replacing the driveway becomes a better option.

Weather Conditions

In South Texas, asphalt driveways often crack from UV exposure. Filling cracks helps temporarily, but major wear requires more.

Pros and Cons: Resurfacing at a Glance

✔ Pros

• Lower driveway repair costs
  
• Fast, clean results
  
• Restores curb appeal
  

✖ Cons

• Doesn’t address concrete repair at the base
  
• Limited lifespan
  
• May only be done once or twice on the same driveway
  

Pros and Cons: Replacing Your Driveway

✔ Pros

• Fixes underlying base issues
  
• Extends overall lifespan
  
• Boosts safety and property value
  

✖ Cons

• Higher upfront installation cost
  
• Longer completion time
  
• May require permits
  

Advice from the Field: What We See in Bulverde and Beyond

Examples of real-life repair options we’ve delivered:

• A concrete driveway repair in Bulverde with minor cracks was successfully resurfaced and sealed, adding 8 years of use.
  
• In Kerrville, a failing old driveway required full excavation, drainage correction, and installation of new concrete.
  
• A commercial asphalt driveway in Boerne with heavy truck traffic needed driveway replacement for durability.
  

Final Thoughts: So, Which Is Better?

Still unsure whether to repair or replace your driveway?

• Choose resurfacing if you’re dealing with cracks in your driveway that don’t affect the structure and your existing driveway is under 15 years old.
  
• Choose replacement for concrete driveways with deep cracks, multiple failed patches, or water damage.
  

Talk to the Experts at C. Brooks Paving

Whether you’re facing cracks and holes, drainage issues, or just want a fresh, safe driveway, our experts can help with driveway repair and replacement. We handle cleaning, repair, and full installation for concrete or asphalt in South Texas. Let us help you make informed decisions and avoid the need for costly replacements down the road.

Frequently Asked Questions